by Alan Matthews - 5/11/2011

Since we may not see any NFL transactions for months, depending on a June 3 court hearing on the lockout, and with the draft still fresh in everyone’s memory, let’s take a look at one of the few NFL player props out so far this year: the 2011 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year (check back at Doc’s for a story on the Offensive Rookie of the Year as well).

WagerWeb lists three players as the early favorites at +500: Denver Broncos linebacker Von Miller (taken No. 2 overall), Arizona Cardinals cornerback Patrick Peterson (No. 5 overall) and Detroit Lions defensive tackle Nick Fairley (No. 13 overall).

Let’s start with Fairley and why I think he’s not good value here. He was probably the “steal” of the first round in most draft experts’ eyes. At one point he was No. 1 on some big boards, but some character issues apparently dropped him into the Lions’ lap. Obviously the guy has mad skills if motivated, as we all saw in the national title game win over Oregon when he almost single-handedly stopped that high-powered Ducks offense. And I’m sure he will have an impact, but I don’t see him playing enough snaps to win Rookie of the Year. Remember that the Lions already are pretty well set at defensive tackle: reigning Rookie of the Year Ndamukong Suh at one spot and Corey Williams at the other. What defensive coordinator Gunther Cunningham will do is rotate Fairley with those two – as good as Suh was last year, Cunningham believes he can be even better by staying fresh. Plus, most defensive tackles, Suh aside, don’t put up gaudy stats, so Fairley isn’t a good bet.

Peterson, no doubt, will start from Day 1 on that Arizona defense. He is likely to see a bunch of balls thrown his way as QBs look to avoid Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie on the other side, so that could mean a nice interception total for Peterson. Plus, he could bring a few kicks back as he is a tremendous return man. Ironically, the Lions tried to trade up to get Peterson. Miller, meanwhile, should thrive at outside linebacker/defensive end in Denver’s new 4-3 defense under Coach John Fox and opposite pass-rushing demon Elvis Dumervil, who will draw all the attention. Some think Miller is the best pure pass-rusher to enter the draft in years. I think he’s the favorite; and also be aware that a linebacker won this award seven straight years before Suh ended that streak in 2010.

Can a Houston Texan win this award for the third time in the past six seasons? I definitely think so. Houston took Wisconsin defensive end J.J. Watt at No. 11 overall and apparently thinks so highly of him that the Texans are moving former No. 1 overall pick Mario Williams to outside linebacker in the team’s new 3-4 defensive scheme. I think Houston’s defense takes a giant leap this year (it can only get better, frankly) under new coordinator Wade Phillips and that Watt is the best value on the board at +1200.

A great longshot option is Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive end Da’Quan Bowers +2000. He was the draft’s biggest slider on defense – at one point he was No. 1 on the big board, too, but slid all the way to the 51st overall pick because of concerns over his knee. Bowers led college football in sacks last year and should start right away, if healthy, as the Bucs were 30th in the NFL in sacks last year. Tampa Bay has a stellar front four of Gerald McCoy and Brian Price at the tackle spots (first- and second-round picks from last year) and Bowers and 2011 first-round pick Adrian Clayborn at the ends. Bowers says he is just slightly motivated to prove all those teams that passed on him wrong.

Here are all of WagerWeb’s options on this prop with their respective NFL odds:

Aaron Williams +1500

Adrian Clayborn +1200

Aldon Smith +1000

Bruce Carter +1000

Cameron Jordan +1200

Corey Liuget +1500

DaQuan Bowers +2000

JJ Watt +1200

Jabaal Sheard +1800

Jimmy Smith +800

Marcell Dareus +650

Marvin Austin +1500

Muhammad Wilkerson +1500

Nick Fairley +500

Patrick Peterson +500

Prince Amukamara +800

Phil Taylor +2000

Robert Quinn +1200

Ryan Kerrigan +1200

Von Miller +500

Cameron Heyward +1500

Field +800
 

Doc's Sports
	Doc’s 10* AL Game of the Night Doc’s Sports is coming off a low odds winner on Monday in the National League and you can expect more of the same on Tuesday with a 10* selection you cannot afford to miss. Sign-up and let Doc provide you this low odds 100% guaranteed winner! - $20.00
	Doc’s 10* NL Game of the Night Doc’s Sports is coming off a low odds winner on Monday in the National League and you can expect more of the same on Tuesday with a 10* selection you cannot afford to miss. Sign-up and let Doc provide you this low odds 100% guaranteed winner! - $20.00
	Doc’s NHL on NBC Smash (12-2 run) Doc’s Sports has you covered on Tuesday with a side play selection from Game 5 of the Western Conference Finals. Doc has dominated the books with their NHL playoff selections all month long and you can expect more of the same on Tuesday night with this 100% guaranteed winner! - $20.00

Click here to view all of Doc's Sports's premium picks.